Watch the KCRA 3 Congressional Debate: District 6 candidates Ami Bera and Christine Bish
Both are running to represent Congressional District 6, which includes Rancho Cordova, Citrus Heights and Sacramento suburbs.
Both are running to represent Congressional District 6, which includes Rancho Cordova, Citrus Heights and Sacramento suburbs.
Both are running to represent Congressional District 6, which includes Rancho Cordova, Citrus Heights and Sacramento suburbs.
With less than a month until the General Election, KCRA 3 is hosting a series of candidate debates for races impacting Northern California.
KCRA 3’s Ashley Zavala moderated a debate between Democratic Rep. Ami Bera and Republican challenger Christine Bish. Both are running to represent Congressional District 6, which includes Rancho Cordova, Citrus Heights and Sacramento suburbs.
Bera has been in office since 2013, representing District 7 until he won the office of District 6 in 2022. He has served as Sacramento County's chief medical officer and as a clinical professor of medicine at UC Davis.
Bish is a small business owner and realtor who has been part of several Sacramento-area community groups over the course of 30 years.
The debate was conducted live to tape on Monday, Oct. 14.
Watch the full debate in the video leading this story. See a recap of questions and answers below.
| Get the Facts | Fact-checking claims made during the Bera-Bish debate
Cost of Living
Question for both candidates: Californians continue to struggle with the high cost of living in this state. What will you push for in Congress to make life here more affordable?
Bera answered first by saying the pandemic was “pretty tough” and disrupted supply chains. He said that while the economy is recovering, “too many working-class, middle-class families are struggling” and cited high gas prices and inflation at grocery stores.
“Obviously, we've got to address the supply chain issues, but we've also got to look at how do we get more goods and products on the shelves, and bring those costs down,” Bera said.
Bera then cited retail theft as impacting the cost of goods and said that must also be addressed.
Pressed for specifics on how he could help bring down prices, Bera said the U.S. could tap petroleum reserves and keep some of what is exported at “home.”
Bish was asked the same question on what she would do to make life more affordable.
She called for “returning to energy independence,” saying that the U.S. economy depends on our gas and fuel supplies.
“Getting into our reserves, which have already been depleted from the last election, in 2022, to help get people over the border,” she said.
Bish said, “we have to start opening up drilling, not only in California, but in Alaska.”
She called for embracing fossil fuels to help drive the economy and make gas and food more affordable.
“We understand that renewable energy is something of the future. But for right now, I'm going to repeat Donald Trump. Drill, baby, drill,” she said.
Abortion
Question for Bish: California is one of 21 states in which state law protects the right and the procedure to an abortion. Following the United States’ Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe vs. Wade, would you support a national abortion ban should you be elected to Congress?
“Absolutely not,” Bish said. She said the Supreme Court sent the abortion issue back to the states “where it belongs” and where voters will decide the policies.
She added that women are struggling.
“Nancy, in Citrus Heights, she’s on a six-month waiting list to get a pap smear,” Bish said.
Bish noted that she is a cancer survivor, “so I understand where our health care is in California and what we have to do to change it to make it more accessible to every person.”
Question for Bera: California is seeing an influx of women as a result of the overturning of Roe vs. Wade. Women seeking reproductive health care are coming from out of state. What would you do or what should Congress do to ensure that the procedure remains accessible not just for women in California, but from those neighboring states?
Bera said he sees the issue from the perspective of a doctor.
“The oath I took was to do good, to do no harm,” he said. “But really to that oath is patient autonomy. Every patient, men and women, should be able to make their own health care decisions.”
He said there is “nothing more personal than reproductive health care decisions.”
Bera said he was proud to be named Planned Parenthood’s legislator of the year as a freshman member and called it a shame that women in California have access to full reproductive health services while women in Texas don’t and doctors in that state don’t get the full OB/GYN they need.
He said Congress should codify some of the protections that Roe vs. Wade had.
Asked what Congress could provide California to help with medical training, Bera said the state is providing some of that funding and “we’ve introduced legislation at the federal level to help support “some of those students that want to get full reproductive training coming in from states like Texas or Missouri.”
Immigration
Question for Bera: Earlier this year, a bipartisan deal to address issues at the southern border fell apart in Congress. Among many things, it would have given the president new power to close the border. It would have required detention and supervision of all migrants processed at the border, and attempted to quickly add more border agents and personnel, plus systems to deal with the judicial backlog. Would you support this measure if revived?
“Absolutely,” Bera said, adding that he has been a supporter. He called the measure smart and bipartisan.
But he called the bill “a starting point, not an ending point.”
“When I think about immigration, I would think about our borders from a national security perspective, because as someone who's on the Intelligence Committee, I do know some of the threats and dangers that are coming across our southern border. But I'd also think about, immigration from an economic perspective,” he said.
He called the U.S. a “nation of immigrants” who bring traditions and cultures together. Bera brought up that his family emigrated from India in the 1950s and said “we shouldn’t lose that heritage.”
Asked why it was so difficult to pass immigration policy in Congress, Bera reiterated that he thinks about the border from a national security perspective and thinks about legal immigration from an economic perspective.
Question for Bish: Same question goes to you if that measure is revived and you were elected to Congress. Would you vote for that bipartisan border deal?
“No,” she said. “I support legal immigration. I also supported the remain-in-Mexico policy.”
She said that Bera protested the remain-in-Mexico policy at the southern border during the Trump administration.
“And under the Biden-Harris administration, we have seen the free-flowing of drugs and human trafficking across the southern border. It has decimated our economy,” Bish said.
She said this has made the homeless crisis worse and “taxed valuable resources as far as food and affordable housing.”
“We don't have to reinvent what's going on at the border,” she said. “We have to enforce the laws that are on the record. Close the open door. I am in favor of continuing the wall, but putting people who are trying to come here legally put them at the front of the line. And we have all but stopped legal immigration.”
Social Security
Question for Bish and Bera: The annual Social Security and Medicare Trustees report released in May said the program’s trust fund will be unable to pay the full benefits beginning in 2035 without any action from Congress. How should Congress address this depletion?
Bish called for protecting seniors who “were taxed when they were paying in. It is reprehensible that we are taxing them when they are now receiving those benefits.”
Bish added that, “we cannot provide benefits to the world. So if you haven't paid in to those benefits, we're seeing Congress now try and push legislation where we would pay Social Security benefits to people coming across the border illegally. So to shore up the program for the people who are currently in it, we need to overhaul who is receiving those benefits.”
She called for “opening up to private Social Security plans.”
Bera called Social Security “one of the most successful programs” that he said has lifted tens of millions of seniors out of poverty.
He said Warren Buffett pays the same amount of Social Security tax as his secretary and “we should actually raise the cap and make sure millionaires and billionaires are paying their fair share into the trust fund.”
Bera called privatizing Social Security “a dangerous thing because then it goes up and down with the stock market.”
Asked how he would ensure the wealthy pay more, Bera said he would raise the cap on the income that would get taxed into Social Security.
Bish responded by saying, “I do not believe we can tax this system into prosperity.” She said right now the program was “not a trust fund. It is a slush fund that has been abused not only by the current Congress, but going back as far as I can remember.”
Housing and Homelessness
Question for Bish and Bera: We heard from many of our viewers who have said that homelessness is a major concern. The most recent local count estimates the number of unhoused people in Sacramento County totals more than 6,600 people. What role should the federal government play in addressing California’s homelessness and housing affordability crisis?
Bera said he agreed that homelessness has become a “much greater challenge” now than it was a decade ago.
“We’re not going to build our way out of this,” he said, adding that seeing someone sleep on the street during extreme heat isn’t compassionate.
He said that people could housed in vacant big box stores if they have wraparound services that could help with addressing underlying issues.
“But the first thing is you do have to get folks off the street to a place where you can actually start to find out what those root cause issues were,” he said.
Bish said that she experienced homelessness as a child in Sacramento.
“So I understand the difference between a hand up and a handout,” she said. “To take a little girl who has lived this life, lived in a car and be able to be in the position that I’m in, it’s based on hard work and choices.”
She said the border crisis with drugs and human trafficking has “challenged our system and it has created much of the homeless problem that we have.”
Bish said she agreed that “we will not build our way out of this” and added that actions at the federal level can create incentives for drug and alcohol treatment.
She blamed illegal immigration for “eating up the valuable resources” for low-income people, including affordable housing.
Question for Bish: How do you propose that Congress address the addiction issues, the incentives that you mentioned?
Bish said that involves securing the border to stop illegal drugs. She also cited Proposition 36 to “start holding criminals accountable.”
She called it a “free for all out there” in relation to shoplifting and drug dealing.
Regulating tech companies
Question for Bish and Bera: Besides the possible TikTok ban, Congress has not done much to regulate the giant growing industry that has impacted everything in society, from youth, mental health to the workforce. Should Congress regulate tech from social media to artificial intelligence? And if so, how?
“We need to start by repealing Section 230 that gives absolute autonomy to the social media world,” Bish said.
She said that her oldest daughter Kara ordered the fentanyl that took her life on social media.
“It was delivered to her house. It’s easier to get than pizza,” she said.
Bish said there is no accountability to the social media company that connected the dealer with her. She also mentioned emotional problems with children.
“Now I do not favor or will support band, but we do need accountability with social media,” she said. “We also need free speech. Right now what we’re seeing is social media companies silencing people for their opinion.”
Bera said he was sorry to hear about Bish’s daughter and agreed that social media should be regulated.
He said there was a need to crack down on dangerous things like human trafficking and the selling of illegal drugs.
“I do think Congress was slow to setting up guardrails on social media, and now we are seeing the impact that has on anxiety, depression, other issues that are plaguing our young people and misinformation as well,” he said.
Bera said he’s on a bipartisan AI taskforce and is working to determine appropriate guardrails.
Bish countered that Bera had more than a decade to address the issue.
In a response, Bera affirmed that Democrats and Republicans should work together.
Bera and Bish then responded to a rapid-fire round of questions. See video of that exchange below.
Question: Should voter identification be required at the polls?
Bera said there’s very little illegal voting and that would “get in the way” of legal voting.
Bish said yes, saying IDs are required to buy spray paint or cold medicine over the counter.
Question: Many viewers submitted the question who won the 2020 election, Joe Biden or former President Donald Trump?
Bish said Joe Biden “was sworn into office. But we do need to secure our elections to make sure that everyone is confident they are fair and secure.”
Bera said Joe Biden won.
Question: Should there be term limits for U.S. Supreme Court justices?
Bera said, “We’ve got to reform the Supreme Court and one of things could be term limits. We should debate that.”
Bish said no.
See the candidates’ closing statements below.
Bish called for emergency independence and for making food, utilities and housing more affordable.
Bera said he was honored to serve Sacramento County for 30 years first as a doctor and then for a decade as a congressman. He called for addressing the cost of living and building more housing.
For more information about the November election, including key issues and other races on the ballot, check out the KCRA 3 Voter Guide.