Skip to content
NOWCAST KCRA 3 News at 11pm
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

California lawmaker says state should withdraw calls for constitutional convention before Trump takes office

California lawmaker says state should withdraw calls for constitutional convention before Trump takes office
THIS IS KCRA THREE NEWS AT 430. A DEMOCRATIC STATE LAWMAKER NOW HAS SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF A U.S. CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION AND WANTS THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE TO WITHDRAW ALL OF THE STATE’S CALLS FOR ONE CONVENTION LIKE THAT. GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM GOT THE STATE LEGISLATURE TO CALL FOR A U.S. CONSTITUTION CONVENTION LAST YEAR, BUT SOME STATE LAWMAKERS ARE CONCERNED, AS SOME REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS ALSO CALL FOR THE GATHERING TO CHANGE THE DOCUMENT. THAT IS THE FOUNDATION OF THE UNITED STATES. KCRA THREE CAPITOL CORRESPONDENT ASHLEY ZAVALA JOINS US NOW IN STUDIO. SO, ASHLEY, WHAT IS THE MAIN CONCERN HERE? YEAH. STATE SENATOR SCOTT WIENER IS WARNING ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF A CONVENTION THAT HE SAYS COULD STRIP FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF PEOPLE IN THE UNITED STATES FROM THOSE RELATED TO ABORTION. THE LGBTQ COMMUNITY AND IMMIGRATION, FOR EXAMPLE, WIENER FILED LEGISLATION THIS WEEK TO BASICALLY RECALL ANY CALIFORNIA REQUEST THAT MADE IN THE LAST CENTURY FOR A U.S. CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION, INCLUDING THE ONE THAT YOU GUYS MENTIONED FROM GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM THAT HE PUSHED FOR LAST YEAR ON GUN CONTROL. WIENER SAYS CALIFORNIA LAWMAKERS SHOULD DO THIS BEFORE TRUMP TAKES OFFICE ON JANUARY 20TH. NOW, WIENER’S CONCERN COMES AS REPUBLICAN TEXAS CONGRESSMAN JODEY ARRINGTON CONTINUES HIS CAMPAIGN FOR A CONVENTION. MOST RECENTLY, HE SAID IT WOULD BE TO DEAL WITH THE COUNTRY’S FINANCIAL DEBT. NOW, IF A CONVENTION WERE TO BE CALLED BY THE NEEDED THRESHOLD OF THREE QUARTERS OF THE STATES, THERE ARE NO RULES AROUND WHAT COULD BE CHANGED OR LIMITS ON TOPICS ACCORDING TO COMMON CAUSE, 28 STATES HAVE ALREADY CALLED FOR THE CONVENTION, MEANING JUST SIX MORE STATES WOULD NEED TO DO SO TO TRIGGER THE CONVENTION. HERE’S WHAT CONCERNS WIENER NOW. REPUBLICANS WILL CONTROL ALL THREE BRANCHES OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, AND OUT OF THE 50 STATE LEGISLATURES, REPUBLICANS CONTROL 28 OF THEM, WHILE DEMOCRATS CONTROL 18 OF THEM. THE REST ARE SPLIT. BESIDES THE ORIGINAL MEETING IN 1787, A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION HAS NEVER HAPPENED. REGARDLESS, DEMOCRATIC STATES HAVE RESCINDED THEIR CALLS SINCE TRUMP FIRST TOOK OFFICE. THAT INCLUDES NEW YORK, NEW JERSEY, OREGON AND ILLINOIS. WIENER SAYS CALIFORNIA NEEDS TO DO THE SAME. WE ARE GETTING DANGEROUSLY CLOSE TO THE NUMBER OF STATES REQUIRED TO ACTUALLY TRIGGER A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION. AND ALTHOUGH THERE ARE MANY THINGS I WOULD LIKE TO REWRITE IN THE CONSTITUTION, WE’RE IN A SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE AN EXTREMIST RIGHT WING NATIONAL GOVERNMENT, AND I PERSONALLY DON’T WANT JIM JORDAN AND DONALD TRUMP AND JD VANCE AND MIKE JOHNSON CONTROLLING WHAT A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION LOOKS LIKE. IT’S PLAYING WITH FIRE. AND CALIFORNIA SHOULD NOT BE A PARTY TO THAT. AND SO THE PRUDENT THING TO DO IS TO JUST WITHDRAW ALL OF OUR REQUESTS FOR A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION, TAKE A BREATH AND SEE IF WE’RE IN A DIFFERENT SPOT IN THE YEARS TO COME. BUT RIGHT NOW, IT’S JUST TOO DANGEROUS. NOW, AS WE MENTIONED EARLIER LAST YEAR, THE STATE LEGISLATURE PASSED GOVERNOR NEWSOM’S PUSH FOR A CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION TO SOLELY FOCUS ON GUN CONTROL. WIENER SUPPORTED NEWSOM’S GUN SAFETY EFFORT, BUT HE WAS OPPOSED TO THAT CALL FOR A CONVENTION. THEN, WITH SOME OF THE CONCERNS HE’S EXPRESSING NOW AROUND THAT LACK OF RULES OR LIMITS ON TOPICS. NOW, WE ASKED FOR A STATEMENT FROM GOVERNOR NEWSOM, BUT NOTHING YET. BACK TO YOU. ALL RIGHT, ASHLEY, THANK YOU. IF CALIFORNIA LAWMAKERS WERE TO WITHDRAW THE CALL FOR A CONVENTION, T
Advertisement
California lawmaker says state should withdraw calls for constitutional convention before Trump takes office
Democratic California state Sen. Scott Wiener this week filed legislation to recall all of the state's requests for a U.S. constitutional convention, citing concerns about how a Republican-controlled federal government could strip away rights and change the document that serves as the country's foundation. Wiener said state lawmakers should pass it before incoming President Donald Trump takes office on Jan. 20. "We are getting dangerously close to the number of states required to actually trigger a constitutional convention, and although there are many things I'd like to rewrite in the Constitution, we are in a situation where we have an extremist, right-wing national government, and I personally don't want Jim Jordan and Donald Trump and JD Vance and Mike Johnson controlling what a constitutional convention looks like," Wiener told KCRA 3 in an interview. Wiener's concern comes after the outcome of the election that will return Donald Trump to the White House and give Republicans control of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the majority of state legislatures (28 of them) have Republican majorities, while 18 of them will be controlled by Democrats. The rest of the states are split.Texas Congressman Jodey Arrington, who is the chairman of the House Budget Committee, has also continued his calls for a constitutional convention, claiming enough states have already called for one and recently stressed the need to convene in order to address the nation's debt. In order to trigger an Article V, or general constitutional convention, 34 states need to call for it. According to Common Cause, 28 states have made the request, meaning six more states are needed to trigger the process. Any changes made to the Constitution through the convention would need to be approved by 38 states. Wiener worries that a lack of rules or limits on topics in an Article V convention could give Conservatives the ability to change various civil liberties or rights nationwide, including those related to abortion, the LGBTQ community and voting. He also noted special business interests could play a major role. "We could see power plays by large corporations to protect their interests baked into the Constitution; we could see all sorts of bad things from my perspective and most Californians' perspective being inserted in the Constitution," Wiener said. "We should not be taking that risk."California has made numerous calls for a constitutional convention in the last century. The most recent one was approved by state lawmakers in 2023 at the request of Gov. Gavin Newsom, who wanted one solely to focus on gun safety. Wiener, at the time, said he supported the governor's efforts on gun safety but opposed the idea of calling for the convention because of the lack of rules around topics.Newsom has not yet weighed in on Wiener's proposal. See more coverage of top California stories here | Download our app | Subscribe to our morning newsletter

Democratic California state Sen. Scott Wiener this week filed legislation to recall all of the state's requests for a U.S. constitutional convention, citing concerns about how a Republican-controlled federal government could strip away rights and change the document that serves as the country's foundation.

Wiener said state lawmakers should pass it before incoming President Donald Trump takes office on Jan. 20.

Advertisement

"We are getting dangerously close to the number of states required to actually trigger a constitutional convention, and although there are many things I'd like to rewrite in the Constitution, we are in a situation where we have an extremist, right-wing national government, and I personally don't want Jim Jordan and Donald Trump and JD Vance and Mike Johnson controlling what a constitutional convention looks like," Wiener told KCRA 3 in an interview.

Wiener's concern comes after the outcome of the election that will return Donald Trump to the White House and give Republicans control of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the majority of state legislatures (28 of them) have Republican majorities, while 18 of them will be controlled by Democrats. The rest of the states are split.

Texas Congressman Jodey Arrington, who is the chairman of the House Budget Committee, has also continued his calls for a constitutional convention, claiming enough states have already called for one and recently stressed the need to convene in order to address the nation's debt.

In order to trigger an Article V, or general constitutional convention, 34 states need to call for it. According to Common Cause, 28 states have made the request, meaning six more states are needed to trigger the process. Any changes made to the Constitution through the convention would need to be approved by 38 states.

Wiener worries that a lack of rules or limits on topics in an Article V convention could give Conservatives the ability to change various civil liberties or rights nationwide, including those related to abortion, the LGBTQ community and voting. He also noted special business interests could play a major role.

"We could see power plays by large corporations to protect their interests baked into the Constitution; we could see all sorts of bad things from my perspective and most Californians' perspective being inserted in the Constitution," Wiener said. "We should not be taking that risk."

California has made numerous calls for a constitutional convention in the last century. The most recent one was approved by state lawmakers in 2023 at the request of Gov. Gavin Newsom, who wanted one solely to focus on gun safety. Wiener, at the time, said he supported the governor's efforts on gun safety but opposed the idea of calling for the convention because of the lack of rules around topics.

Newsom has not yet weighed in on Wiener's proposal.

See more coverage of top California stories here | Download our app | Subscribe to our morning newsletter