Skip to content
NOWCAST KCRA 3 News at 11pm
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

Understanding the spread of bird flu from animals to humans

Understanding the spread of bird flu from animals to humans
THAT’S GREAT NEWS TO HEAR. DID NOT KNOW THAT. SO LET’S TALK ABOUT MILK MYTHS. MILK FACTS. AS YOU KNOW, HERE IN MASSACHUSETTS, YOU CAN’T BUY RAW MILK IN STORES. YOU HAVE TO GO TO A FARM TO BUY IT DIRECTLY FROM THERE. DOES THAT MAKE IT SAFER TO DRINK? AND IS IT SAFE TO DRINK RAW MILK? I THINK HERE’S THE BOTTOM LINE. CDC SHOWED THAT OVER A 20 YEAR PERIOD, THERE WERE ABOUT 202 OUTBREAKS FROM RAW MILK. OKAY, THAT’S THAT’S IMPORTANT. FOODBORNE ILLNESS FROM RAW MILK COMPARED TO NINE FROM PASTEURIZED MILK. SO OVERALL PASTEURIZED MILK IS SAFER FROM AN INFECTIOUS PERSPECTIVE. BUT THE ABSOLUTE RISK IS LOW. THERE ARE OVER 10 MILLION PEOPLE DRINKING RAW MILK EVERY YEAR, AND THERE ARE ROUGHLY ABOUT TEN HOSPITALIZATIONS FROM THAT RAW MILK. NOW, I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR. CDC DOES NOT RECOMMEND THAT WE DRINK RAW MILK. OKAY. AND I BELIEVE THAT IF YOU ARE IN A VULNERABLE POPULATION, EXTREMES OF AGE, PREGNANT WOMEN, IMMUNOCOMPROMISED, YOU REALLY SHOULD AVOID RAW MILK. BUT IN OTHER HEALTHY PEOPLE, I THINK THE BOTTOM LINE IS WE ALWAYS HAVE TO KNOW THE RISKS, THE BENEFITS AND THE ALTERNATIVES. JUST LIKE WITH EATING RAW OYSTERS, JUST LIKE GREEN LEAFY VEGETABLES, GREEN LEAFY VEGETABLES MAKE UP ABOUT 10% OF FOODBORNE ILLNESS. BUT OF COURSE, THERE ARE SO MANY POSITIVE NUTRIENTS WITH THAT. I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE, THOUGH, WHEN THEY THINK ABOUT RAW MILK, ESPECIALLY NOW THERE’S BEEN A SPIKE, IT SEEMS LIKE A SURGE OF MORE PEOPLE INTERESTED. THEY THINK I HEAR A LOT OF TALK ABOUT, HEY, IT’S THE NUTRITIONAL VALUE. ALSO, GOOD FOR YOUR GUT. WHAT SAY YOU ABOUT THAT? ALL RIGHT. SO NOW YOU’RE ASKING ABOUT THE BENEFITS OF RAW MILK. AND I THINK WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE SCIENCE, AT LEAST IT DOESN’T NECESSARILY SUPPORT THE BENEFITS OVER PASTEURIZED MILK. PROBIOTICS, FOR EXAMPLE, ARE SUPPOSED TO COME FROM HUMAN GUT BACTERIA. THE BACTERIA THAT’S IN RAW MILK IS FROM THE COW’S UDDER. SO I THINK THAT’S ONE THING. SOME PEOPLE THINK THAT YOU CAN CURE LACTOSE INTOLERANCE BY DRINKING RAW MILK. LACTOSE INTOLERANCE HAS NOTHING TO DO, WHETHER IT’S RAW OR WHETHER IT’S PASTEURIZED. SO I THINK SOME OF THESE ARE MYTHS. OBVIOUSLY, SOME PEOPLE LIKE THE TASTE OF IT BETTER. IT CAN BE CREAMIER. AND IF YOU DO AND YOU’RE OTHERWISE HEALTHY, I THINK THAT’S OKAY. AS LONG AS YOU REALIZE THERE IS A SMALL INCREASED RISK OF FOODBORNE ILLNESS AND SOME OF THOSE ILLNESSES LIKE LISTERIA, SALMONELLA, CAMPYLOBACTER CAN BE VERY SERIOUS, WHICH IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW TO JUST GET THE INFORMATION, THE FACTS, BEFORE YOU MAKE YOUR DECISION. RIGHT. BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE JUST LIKE THE TASTE, RIGHT? OR THEY JUST PREFER, YOU KNOW, SOMETHING ELSE. BUT IT’S NOT NECESSARILY ALWAYS ABOUT THE NUTRITIONAL VALUE, WHICH MAY NOT NECESSARILY BE THERE. AGREE. AND WE STARTED WITH BIRD FLU. THE QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER BIRD FLU WILL BE TRANSMITTED THROUGH RAW MILK, THAT’S STILL A QUESTION MARK. THERE HAVEN’T BEEN CASES BUT IT’S STILL EARLY. SO I THINK THAT QUESTIONS UNANSWERED. SO WE HAVE TO BE CAUTIOUS. YOU CAN TALK ABOUT THIS FOR A LONG TIME. WE HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS HERE. BUT DOCTOR WE ALWAYS APPRECIA
Advertisement
Understanding the spread of bird flu from animals to humans
As bird flu infections rise in dairy cattle and chickens, human cases are ticking up too, leaving many people to wonder whether they might be at risk from this recently arrived virus.Bird flu infections are rare in people. Sixty-one human cases have been confirmed in the U.S. this year, according to the U.S., Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and all but three have been in people who work on poultry or dairy farms.As the name suggests, avian influenza viruses prefer to infect birds. They break into cells by latching onto sugars that stick up from their surfaces called sialic acids. H5N1, the bird flu virus behind the ongoing outbreak in the U.S., has really only demonstrated an affinity for the types of sialic acid receptors that are most plentiful in the respiratory tracts of birds.But flu viruses can also mutate quickly, and since 2022, H5N1 has been infecting a growing variety of mammals, including dairy cattle.That has scientists on alert because the more it circulates in animals, the better it gets at finding new hosts.A study published last week in the journal Science showed that just one key change to the virus’ genetic material would allow it to attach to the kinds of sialic acids that are most common in the nose and lungs of people. But it’s nearly impossible to predict when that could happen — or if it ever will.Animal-to-human spillover eventsWhen humans have become infected with bird flu, it’s almost always been through contact with infected animals. All but one of these so-called spillover infections have been mild.The United States’ first severe case was announced this week in a person in Louisiana who remains hospitalized in critical condition. The CDC said Wednesday the person was exposed to sick and dead birds on their property, not from commercial poultry.No one who has gotten H5N1 in the U.S. is known to have given the infection to anyone else. For that reason, the CDC estimates that the current risk to the public is low, but there are certain occupations and situations that can increase a person’s risk of catching bird flu.The two groups of people who are most at risk are farm workers who work with cows or poultry and people who keep backyard flocks, said Dr. Michael Osterholm, who directs the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota.Birds shed the virus through their saliva, mucus and feces, and it can become airborne when their litter and feathers are churned up in barns, particularly during culling operations.“It can be in the air,” Osterholm said. “So it’s not even just contact touching the birds but just the dander and all the dust that occurs when you’re dealing with birds.”The virus also homes in on the udders of milking cows, and studies have found high concentrations of bird flu virus in milk that is raw or unpasteurized.The milking parlors of dairies are wet environments, and workers can be infected if they get a splash of raw milk in their eyes or if they get milk on their hands and then rub their eyes. Droplets of virus-laden milk can also become airborne if they spray from milking equipment.One of the most prominent symptoms in infected farm workers has been red, irritated eyes, or conjunctivitis. That may be because human eyes share the same types of sialic acid receptors that are most common in birds.Risks from raw milkWhat about drinking raw milk?Cats have been infected after drinking raw cow’s milk. There have also been reports of calves getting sick after drinking infected milk.“We don’t have those same data for humans,” Osterholm said.No human infections have been linked to raw milk consumption, although a toddler in California recently tested positive for influenza after drinking a large amount of raw milk. The CDC wasn’t able to confirm whether the infection was bird flu, however, so this child is listed as a suspected case.But there’s plenty of data on other pathogens that can be found in raw milk, even without specific evidence for H5N1. In 2023 and 2024, outbreaks of E. coli and salmonella infections were traced back to raw milk. It can harbor other pathogens like listeria and Campylobacter, too.Pasteurization kills all these harmful germs, including H5N1, a recent government study shows.However, refrigeration does not. A recent study from Stanford University that involved lacing raw milk with flu virus and testing it on cells in a Petri dish found that the virus could still infect cells for up to five days after being refrigerated.Staying safeThe best way to protect yourself from bird flu is to avoid sources of exposure, according to the CDC.People can catch bird flu when enough virus gets into their eyes, nose or mouth or when they breathe it in. This usually takes close, prolonged exposure to infected animals.For that reason, the CDC recommends that people stay away from sick or dead birds or other animals, and avoid touching surfaces contaminated with feces or saliva, such as litter or bedding.If you do have to handle sick birds, cows or other animals, such as in a farm or rescue setting, the CDC recommends wearing appropriate personal protective equipment, or PPE. This includes:GogglesDisposable glovesAn N95 face maskCoverallsRubber bootsBecause raw milk can carry so many dangerous germs, experts advise avoiding it and sticking to pasteurized dairy products.But what about raw eggs? The U.S. Food and Drug Administration says it’s unlikely that eggs from an infected flock would make it onto store shelves because birds rapidly become sick from bird flu, and there are safeguards in place, such as inspections, to prevent contaminated eggs from reaching the market.It’s still a good idea to cook eggs and poultry to a safe temperature and prevent cross-contamination between raw and cooked foods in the kitchen.

As bird flu infections rise in dairy cattle and chickens, human cases are ticking up too, leaving many people to wonder whether they might be at risk from this recently arrived virus.

Bird flu infections are rare in people. Sixty-one human cases have been confirmed in the U.S. this year, according to the U.S., Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and all but three have been in people who work on poultry or dairy farms.

Advertisement

As the name suggests, avian influenza viruses prefer to infect birds. They break into cells by latching onto sugars that stick up from their surfaces called sialic acids. H5N1, the bird flu virus behind the ongoing outbreak in the U.S., has really only demonstrated an affinity for the types of sialic acid receptors that are most plentiful in the respiratory tracts of birds.

But flu viruses can also mutate quickly, and since 2022, H5N1 has been infecting a growing variety of mammals, including dairy cattle.

That has scientists on alert because the more it circulates in animals, the better it gets at finding new hosts.

A study published last week in the journal Science showed that just one key change to the virus’ genetic material would allow it to attach to the kinds of sialic acids that are most common in the nose and lungs of people. But it’s nearly impossible to predict when that could happen — or if it ever will.

Animal-to-human spillover events

When humans have become infected with bird flu, it’s almost always been through contact with infected animals. All but one of these so-called spillover infections have been mild.

The United States’ first severe case was announced this week in a person in Louisiana who remains hospitalized in critical condition. The CDC said Wednesday the person was exposed to sick and dead birds on their property, not from commercial poultry.

No one who has gotten H5N1 in the U.S. is known to have given the infection to anyone else. For that reason, the CDC estimates that the current risk to the public is low, but there are certain occupations and situations that can increase a person’s risk of catching bird flu.

The two groups of people who are most at risk are farm workers who work with cows or poultry and people who keep backyard flocks, said Dr. Michael Osterholm, who directs the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota.

Birds shed the virus through their saliva, mucus and feces, and it can become airborne when their litter and feathers are churned up in barns, particularly during culling operations.

“It can be in the air,” Osterholm said. “So it’s not even just contact touching the birds but just the dander and all the dust that occurs when you’re dealing with birds.”

The virus also homes in on the udders of milking cows, and studies have found high concentrations of bird flu virus in milk that is raw or unpasteurized.

The milking parlors of dairies are wet environments, and workers can be infected if they get a splash of raw milk in their eyes or if they get milk on their hands and then rub their eyes. Droplets of virus-laden milk can also become airborne if they spray from milking equipment.

One of the most prominent symptoms in infected farm workers has been red, irritated eyes, or conjunctivitis. That may be because human eyes share the same types of sialic acid receptors that are most common in birds.

Risks from raw milk

What about drinking raw milk?

Cats have been infected after drinking raw cow’s milk. There have also been reports of calves getting sick after drinking infected milk.

“We don’t have those same data for humans,” Osterholm said.

No human infections have been linked to raw milk consumption, although a toddler in California recently tested positive for influenza after drinking a large amount of raw milk. The CDC wasn’t able to confirm whether the infection was bird flu, however, so this child is listed as a suspected case.

But there’s plenty of data on other pathogens that can be found in raw milk, even without specific evidence for H5N1. In 2023 and 2024, outbreaks of E. coli and salmonella infections were traced back to raw milk. It can harbor other pathogens like listeria and Campylobacter, too.

Pasteurization kills all these harmful germs, including H5N1, a recent government study shows.

However, refrigeration does not. A recent study from Stanford University that involved lacing raw milk with flu virus and testing it on cells in a Petri dish found that the virus could still infect cells for up to five days after being refrigerated.

Staying safe

The best way to protect yourself from bird flu is to avoid sources of exposure, according to the CDC.

People can catch bird flu when enough virus gets into their eyes, nose or mouth or when they breathe it in. This usually takes close, prolonged exposure to infected animals.

For that reason, the CDC recommends that people stay away from sick or dead birds or other animals, and avoid touching surfaces contaminated with feces or saliva, such as litter or bedding.

If you do have to handle sick birds, cows or other animals, such as in a farm or rescue setting, the CDC recommends wearing appropriate personal protective equipment, or PPE. This includes:

  • Goggles
  • Disposable gloves
  • An N95 face mask
  • Coveralls
  • Rubber boots

Because raw milk can carry so many dangerous germs, experts advise avoiding it and sticking to pasteurized dairy products.

But what about raw eggs? The U.S. Food and Drug Administration says it’s unlikely that eggs from an infected flock would make it onto store shelves because birds rapidly become sick from bird flu, and there are safeguards in place, such as inspections, to prevent contaminated eggs from reaching the market.

It’s still a good idea to cook eggs and poultry to a safe temperature and prevent cross-contamination between raw and cooked foods in the kitchen.